Productivity Commission (PC) has released their final conclusions and there are
a range of findings affecting the payments system. One of these which sparked
interest was the recommendation to “introduce a ban on card payment interchange
fees by the end of 2019. Any other fees should be made transparent and
To me, executing this resolution without broad consideration for the impacts on card payments, feels akin to Alice in Wonderland heading down a rabbit hole to a world that is not fully understood, complex, problematic and challenging, and increasingly so the further one goes down.
There are many arguments for an against interchange fees, too many for me to go into here. But I do want to mention a few. There is an argument that in a mature payment system, interchange fees are less relevant as compared to a new payment system where interchange goes some way to assisting in the development of new infrastructure, products and features.
However, given there is continued evolution in card payment systems, with developments including the introduction of EMV cards, contactless, mobile, tokenisation, to name a few, there is never truly a mature—or more appropriately—a static, fully evolved card payment system. Card systems continue to change and therefore the argument about interchange assisting in the development costs, still holds, even though the international schemes—Visa and MasterCard are both roughly half a century old, and it could be argued they are well and truly mature.
So on the basis of ongoing innovation, interchange remains relevant, and a ban on interchange fees—whether this be a removal of interchange or the setting of interchange to zero—is in effect setting interchange to an arbitrary rate without appropriate analysis backing up this position.
In the early 2000’s, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) conducted a cost study which, amongst other things, considered the costs of issuer and acquirer. This led to the setting of interchange at 0.53% - 0.55% for debit and credit cards (down from about 1.0%). After subsequent reviews, the RBA made further changes and set credit interchange to 0.50% and 12c a transaction for debit and more recently a change to debit interchange from 12c to 8c a transaction.
Whether participants in the payments industry agreed or not with the RBA’s conclusion, there was sufficient examination—based on evidence—of the costs and other factors, to make their conclusions on interchange sound, or at least, based on thorough investigation.
That said, I believe a more appropriate step following the PC conclusions is to recommend the RBA re-examine interchange with a view to determining whether any factors have changed since the last review. If so, this may lead to a change in the interchange rates, but if the RBA’s prior practices are anything to go by, this examination would be thorough, based on sound principles and unlikely to be driven by an end point in mind.
So—my preference is to have an examination take place by the RBA, and for it to take into account the economics and payment system dynamics, before regulation is amended.
In keeping with my Alice in Wonderland analogy, let’s look down the rabbit hole first, before we jump headlong in.
Author: Michael Swannell, Associate, Payments Consulting Network, Brisbane
If you found this article helpful and would be interested in reading similar articles by our consulting team, please sign up to our email newsletter or download our most recent newsletter at https://www.merchantpricing.com/newsletter-archive.
Merchant Service Fees – Lean in and Learn Posted on: 19-10-2018
Did you know Merchants can negotiate their cost of Merchant Service Fees to improve their profit margins? This may be a very big surprise to the many thousands of merchants around Australia who have accepted the percentage buried somewhere in a contract.Read More
Australian Regulator ‘Unlikely’ To Embrace Interchange Fee Ban Posted on: 16-08-2018
The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) is said to be “hesitant” to lower interchange fees to zero, after the government received recommendations to ban the charge by the end of next year.Read More
Key Recommendations of the Productivity Commission Final Report into Competition in the Financial System Posted on: 14-08-2018
Australia’s Treasurer released the long anticipated Productivity Commission Final Report into Competition in the Financial System. This report builds on David Murray’s Financial System Inquiry (FSI) and Wallis Inquiry.Read More
What is Interchange and Why Does it Matter? Posted on: 01-08-2018
Even if you have never heard the term ‘interchange’ this article is for you as we look at what it is, why it exists and whether it matters to merchants who accept scheme-branded (Visa, Mastercard and eftpos) payment cards either online, in-store or both.Read More
Payments Consulting Network Selected as One of Westpac’s 2018 Businesses of Tomorrow Posted on: 25-07-2018
Payments Consulting Network – which runs Merchant Pricing Hub – has been selected as one of Westpac’s 2018 Businesses of Tomorrow.Read More
Square is Partnering with BoQ to Help More Small Businesses Get Started Posted on: 19-07-2018
New Bank of Queensland small business customers who sign up for business banking services will now receive a free Square reader with free payments processing for their first $1000 of sales.Read More
Tyro ‘Tap & Save’ Merchants Achieve Up to 20 Percent Savings Posted on: 12-06-2018
Tyro has achieved over 10 percent conversion of existing merchants and solid increase in new merchant sign ups since its launch of least cost routing in March 2018.Read More
Major Card Schemes Zero in on Single 'Buy' Button for Online Commerce Posted on: 19-04-2018
Both Visa and Mastercard have set out their plans to support the new EMVCo Secure Remote Commerce (SRC) framework in a bid to create a ubiquitous online shopping technology standard backed by token-only storage of payment details.Read More
Westpac to Offer Cheaper Tap and Go Payments for Retailers Posted on: 05-04-2018
Westpac has joined its rivals in committing to give small businesses a choice by 2019 on whether they want contactless dual network debit card payments to be sent through the lower-cost eftpos network, rather than via the international card schemes.Read More